Lectures for Doctoral Science Education students from June to early August were still less active than usual. However, to optimize student potential in fulfilling publication outcomes, the Study Program assists in writing articles. It coincides with the ongoing visiting professor activities. Assistance will be held Wednesday, August 9, 2023, at 14.00 WIB for 120 minutes. PhD students in Science Education attended this activity, and Prof. Muammer Calik, a reviewer. Prof. Muammer Calik comes from Trabzon University, Turkey. He is also an editor and reviewer of reputable international journals. Prof. Muammer Calik's research interest concerns socio-scientific issues, scientific thinking habits, and learning strategies. He is also involved in writing literature reviews, whether thematic reviews, systematic literature reviews, or meta-analyses.

The discussion, which lasted approximately two hours, was attended by ten Science Education PhD students. However, on this occasion, only three students could present the article manuscripts they had written. Three students, namely Desy Purwasih, Astuti Wijayanti, and Wenny Pinta Litna. After presenting the article, Prof. Muammer provided a review to improve the article manuscript. Even though there are many improvements given to each article manuscript, Prof. Muammer stated, "The review given is a step to improve the quality of the manuscript that has been prepared." He hopes that after improvements are made, students will immediately publish in international journals.